Plaster cracks stay closed with four steps: open each crack, fill it with setting-type compound, bridge the ones that move with fiberglass mesh, and seal the wall with a bonding primer before paint. Filler and paint alone usually crack again along the same line.
A lot of New Orleans was built before drywall became the norm. Walk through a raised shotgun in Mid-City, a Garden District side hall or a Bywater cottage and you’ll often find the original plaster over wood lath, sometimes with a few patches of newer drywall where a wall was opened up. Those houses sit on soft ground and settle, and plaster records every bit of that movement as a crack.
That’s why the repair method matters more than the paint.
Why do cracks in plaster keep coming back?
Movement. The house shifts on its piers, the lath swells and shrinks with moisture, and every slammed door sends a small jolt through the wall. A crack that’s only been filled with premixed spackle has nothing holding it together, so the next bit of movement reopens it along the same line.
Loose plaster is the other cause. Plaster grips the lath through small ridges called keys, pushed between the boards when the wall was built. Over decades some keys break, and a section of wall starts to flex. Patch the surface of a flexing section and the crack is back by next season.
Some cracks point to a bigger problem than paint can solve. A crack that runs at an angle from the corner of a door or window, is wider at one end, or comes back wider each time points to movement in the structure. Have that looked at before anyone paints over it.
How do you repair and paint plaster walls, step by step?
Before any scraping or sanding in a home built before 1978, find out if lead is in the old paint layers. Federal rules under the EPA’s Renovation, Repair and Painting Program set how that paint is disturbed, and our post on lead-safe painting in New Orleans explains it for homeowners. Then the repair goes like this:
- Check for loose plaster. Press along each crack with a flat hand. If the wall moves or sounds hollow when tapped, reattach it to the lath with plaster washers and screws before anything else.
- Open the crack. Rake it out into a shallow V with a utility knife so the filler has something to grip, then brush out the dust.
- Fill with setting-type compound. The kind you mix from powder hardens chemically and shrinks far less than premixed spackle.
- Tape the cracks that move. Embed fiberglass mesh tape in setting compound over any crack that has opened before, then feather out wide, thin coats on top.
- Sand and check. Sand smooth, wipe off the dust and hold a work light flat against the wall.
- Prime. Use a bonding primer or one rated for plaster over the patches and the whole wall. New compound and old plaster absorb paint differently, and without primer the patches show through as dull spots.
- Paint. Two finish coats, cut in carefully at the tall baseboards, crown and transoms.

It’s slower than fill-and-paint. It’s also the version that lasts.
Does New Orleans weather change how plaster gets repaired?
Yes, mostly in drying time. Premixed compound dries by evaporation, and in damp air it can stay soft underneath for a long time after the surface feels dry. Primer over a patch that’s still wet inside can bubble.
Setting-type compound helps here because it hardens by reaction instead of drying. Running the air conditioning to pull moisture out of the room helps too. More on that in our guide to prep work in the New Orleans climate.
Should you skim coat plaster instead of patching it?
When a wall has a web of fine cracks across most of its surface, often called map cracking, patching one crack at a time leaves a lumpy wall. A skim coat, a thin layer of compound over the whole wall, gives you one even surface to prime and paint.
For a wall with a few distinct cracks, patching is the better fit. It keeps more of the original plaster texture, and skim coating adds time, so it’s a call to make wall by wall.
Waiting rarely saves anything. A crack left alone tends to grow, and plaster with broken keys can sag and eventually let go.
How do you know how much plaster repair your walls need?
Walk each room with a flashlight held flat to the wall and mark cracks and bulges with painter’s tape.
At a free in-person estimate, we walk the walls with you, press on the suspect spots and talk through what each one needs. Drywall repair and paint prep are part of our residential interior painting. Plaster repair is specialist work, so if a wall needs it, we’ll tell you and paint once it’s done. For how prep changes the overall scope, see what drives the cost to paint a house interior.
Frequently Asked Questions
What primer should you use on old plaster walls?
Old plaster walls need a bonding primer or a primer rated for plaster, applied over the patches and the full wall. It seals the different textures of old plaster and new compound so paint dries evenly. Over water stains or smoke marks, a stain-blocking primer goes on first so the marks don’t bleed through.
Can you use drywall mud on plaster cracks?
Drywall mud can be used on plaster cracks, but setting-type compound is the better choice for the fill. It hardens by chemical reaction, shrinks less and stands up to movement better than premixed mud. Premixed compound works for the thin finishing coats on top once the crack is filled and taped.
Is it safe to sand old plaster walls?
Sanding old plaster walls is safe only after you know what’s in the paint. In a home built before 1978, painted layers can contain lead, and federal EPA rules govern how contractors disturb it. Testing first, then using containment and dust control, keeps the work safe for the household.
How long should plaster patches dry before painting?
Patches in plaster should dry completely through before primer goes on, and the product label gives the minimum time. Setting-type compound hardens on a fixed schedule, while premixed compound depends on the air. In humid New Orleans weather, premixed patches can take much longer than the label suggests, so test the patch before priming.
Can you paint plaster walls without fixing the cracks?
Plaster walls can be painted without fixing the cracks, but the cracks will show through the new paint, often within months. Paint has no strength to hold a crack closed. Opening, filling, taping and priming each crack first is what keeps the new finish smooth for years instead of one season.
Before we call a paint job done, we walk every wall with you surface by surface, and the work is covered by our workmanship warranty. To have someone look at your walls, schedule a free in-person estimate or call (504) 399-5399.


